Originally Posted by anthropic
.... While I agree that Popper's falsification criterion is attractive (indeed, I used to teach it in economics class), not every theory or idea can be falsified, even in principle. .

Yeah. I don't call that science. That's metaphysics. A theory must be expressible in the language of mathematics and it must predict the outcomes of experiments that if not in agreement would falsify it.

Quote
... it (is) best to check their claims against the observational record.

Can't find any fault there, that is exactly what I did.


It isn't what we don't know that gives us trouble, it's what we know that ain't so - Will Rogers