CANCEL THE FISH ORDER!!!!
Think through the suggestions above.
If you must add to what you have, look for a way to block off part of your pond or have a second forage pond that can be a grow out cell. Then you could truly buy 'stocker' size fish and then release them when the time is right and they are larger..
Or a heavy fish and cull program that may take a long time.
If you really want a different backbone of the dominant predator vs the most needed forage, and if you want to be less affected by the constant battle (often losing) of maintaining FEW enough LMB, and the correct size classes of forage and bluegill, you could consider a reset. A couple hundred of dollars spent on rotenone, wait 30 days, double check you have a clean slate, and you have 2 acres of freedom. Or to save money and better assure a clean slate, pump it down or use any existing drain pipe you have and you will need less rotenone. Then, when empty you can start all your future small forage at the same time. Then add a few of your preferred predators, add in YP at a cheaper stocker size without fear of predation as they will be the biggest fish in the pond Let them establish and spawn and create their own stocker YP the next spring. Add some bonus species if you like (pickeral, NP, HSB) in small quantities at a small size to save on cost without fear of predation.
If you want to go back to a LMB/BG dynamic you can easily add that back in at anytime and the population of those two will explode again.
The current CC will be eating machines and make future stocking challenging. They likely are reproducing adding to the pond imbalance. They probably can't all be harvested by angling so that variable is 'stuck' in the equation too. They are a once in, always in kind of problem for you in 2 acres.
The most telling part of your post above was 'Everybody is sick of catching LMB, BG, and CC"
That means everyone is about ready to significantly change the main fish species of the pond.
I can totally understand though where you worked hard to get very nice size panfish and it is hard to start over!!
