I like both, in their place.
I like the the natural part of our farms at times of the year when they are pleasant. Spring and fall is nice. As far as my ponds, I don't keep them "city" manicured, but I do keep them mowed and accessible, trees and brush off the dam, all weather access.
I feed the fish because it is one of my most enjoyable aspects of the pond. I'm not really trying for trophy's, but when I go "fishing" I prefer catching over actually fishing. I get bored pretty quick if I am not catching anything. Not much of an agler really.
Like you say, personal preference.
