I would seek the advice of a lawyer before deciding what to do or giving this guy any more money. Many lawyers will give you the initial consult free. Get the new work order in writing, he sold you a pond that wasn't fit to be a pond in the first place. You might be better off hiring someone else since he's not backing up his original work and charging you more to "fix" his work. What a nightmare.

[Linked Image from i108.photobucket.com]