Theo asks: “What are each of your end goals for your big male BG, besides the shear pride and thrill of growing/catching them?” Theo, I think this question is just a sneaky way of trying to get a preview of Part 3 of Behemoth Bluegills by Cody, Condello and Baird.
Part 3 of Raising Behemoth Bluegill (Management) discussess among other things a few reasons for using, recognizing, and selecting male bluegills, such as: A. improving existing BG populations, B. reducing competition while improving body condition, C. enhancing size structure of BG in a pond, E. using the males to exert a social influence among existing BG, and F. their use as a bonus fish.
In addition my interests in male bluegill are numerous.
1. I can have the benefits of bluegills AND not have to put up with the problems of over population and slow growth.
2. Feed trained bluegills typically hang out higher in the water column than yellow perch. Since the bluegills are first to start eating the floating fish food, they provide signals to the deeper dwelling perch that it is feeding time. BG in a pond may help a larger percentage of the perch "stay on" fish pellets.
3. I think that a few bluegill cause the yellow perch to feed slightly more aggressively due to competition compared to if no bluegill are present.
4. I have discovered that a few Bluegills in a yellow perch pond function as “teacher fish” or examples and help newly introduced fed trained perch to find the feeding area. I think bluegills feeding at the surface can help train my young perch or, hesitant but willing perch, to learn to eat fish food. BG may also help train perch to be less shy at coming to the surface for food.
5. Occasionally I like a few bluegill fillets mixed in with a main dinner serving of yellow perch.
6. A few male bluegills mixed into another type of fishery provide a little diversity to the fish catching and enjoyment.
7. When I catch a bluegill it is a lot more “fun” (for me, maybe not the fish) if it is 10” or longer.
8. I really appreciate the quality of a trophy bluegill that is longer than 10”.
9. Cecil makes a very good point that few if any fish farms market high quality, fast growing, and premium bluegills. Very few hatcheries in Michigan even sell pure strain bluegill. I think there is a market for premium fast growing bluegill. Bruce has spent several years developing and is continuing selective breeding of a strain of bluegill that is premium. A living product like this takes time and has good value and can demand a premium price due to the time effort that it takes to reach a high quality end product (brood stock). The time and space factor is probably why a lot of fish farms have not done this. The fish farm can make more money using the pond for raising other higher profit fingerlings compared to the “average”, “run of the mill” bluegill. Most people who buy pond fish do not realize that all BG are not just BG. I would pay a premium for some BG from Bruce’s BG Farm.