Could you tell us a little more about your pond? How big? How deep? How bad of an FA problem? 50? 70? 90 percent???
If I were starting over now and just got my pond and could not afford air. I would.......
Learn what to use to control my FA to some degree. Have my water tested to see if it needs anything. Start catching LMB and getting some RW's on them. If they are below 90 percent RW I would get rid of them.
I would say do an electroshock of your pond to see what you have but if you cant afford air I'm sure you cant afford shocking your pond right now either....
When you catch your fish do they look healthy? Do they have any kind of black specs on them or parasites or little critters moving around on their scales??? Or do they just look skinny? If it's option 1 then you may need some RES in your pond to help with possible snails that are being used as hosts for the parasites....
IMO if you have ducks or geese get rid of them they do nothing but make a mess in your pond and leave possible parasites in your pond from there bird crap and their mouth all kinds a ways....
Oh and I would also buy the book Perfect Pond Want One? In the PondBoss store. Lots of great info in that book!!!
RC
RC - thanks for making me think
“Could you tell us a little more about your pond? How big? How deep? How bad of an FA problem? 50? 70? 90 percent???”
The total size of the pond, based on Google maps and measurement toos, is about 1.52 acres. I own about .57 acres of it, and the abandonded house/lot next door owns the rest (I know that is a separate issue, may be some legal issues down the road - ill cross those bridges if and when i need to).
I am not certain how deep. I was able to find a used pond pounder this week for a OUTSTANDING price and will be paddling around the pond and getting depths. I would be surprised if it is deeper than 10 feet.
I say i have a FA problem because I would get caught up in it while fishing and it is all over the shoreline perimeter, but maybe I don't. I would say less than 20% of the entire pond has FA.
“Learn what to use to control my FA to some degree. Have my water tested to see if it needs anything. Start catching LMB and getting some RW's on them. If they are below 90 percent RW I would get rid of them”
I will figure out if I really do have a FA problem and get my water tested ASAP. I have been keeping mental records of my catches but do need to get them on paper. I know my smallest LMB was 9” and would not even register on my scale (I will get a better scale). The largest was 12” and weighed .7 lbs. I will be having friends and family come catch what they can and I will try to have a slot limit established by then.
“I would say do an electroshock of your pond to see what you have but if you cant afford air I'm sure you cant afford shocking your pond right now either....”
Would love to electrofish – but even if I had the money, I am not sure my pond would be accessible for their boat/trailer without taking fences down and the CMO (Chief Marriage Officer – aka my wife) would not like that too much. And… while I cannot afford the air setup I want, and since I don’t own the entire pond and will wait until someone buys that land (been vacant since 2008 and if I could just buy the land without the crappy house I would do it), I did do some googling and found a way to do something. I know it is not going to help the entire pond, but I felt something, even temporary, is better than nothing for what I do own. So, I have a sump pump throwing water onto the surface. Not sure that is getting more oxygen in the water, but I have noticed 100’s of minnows in that area, whereas I never saw anything but moss there before. That’s cool to me  I am building a pvc venturi device this weekend that I am hoping will do a better job.
“When you catch your fish do they look healthy? Do they have any kind of black specs on them or parasites or little critters moving around on their scales??? Or do they just look skinny? If it's option 1 then you may need some RES in your pond to help with possible snails that are being used as hosts for the parasites....”
Fish look healthy – good color – no critters. Just look small and skinny
“ IMO if you have ducks or geese get rid of them they do nothing but make a mess in your pond and leave possible parasites in your pond from there bird crap and their mouth all kinds a ways.... “
We have 2 migratory Canadian geese that do not appear to be old enough little ones, and other occasional visits from migrators as they come/go, but no year round birds – all wild.
“Oh and I would also buy the book Perfect Pond Want One? In the PondBoss store. Lots of great info in that book!!!”
Will definitely pick it up in the near future. Thanks!