Greg,

Havent you figured it out yet, our Ichthyology class was a waste of time. Class should have been titled The History of Fishes.

Green sunfish dorsal fin with 10(9-11) spines and 11(10-12)soft rays. Anal fin soft rays 9-10(8-11) Pectoral fin rays 13-15

Warmouth - dorsal fin with 10(9-11) spines and usually 10 soft rays. anal fin soft rays 9-10 pectoral fin rays 12-13

I see those "black" greensunfish a couple times a year in my shocking surveys.