FWIW, I�ll relate a personal experience on acceptance of flies for record fish.
A number of years ago I developed a fly called a Spinster.
It had a small spinner/swivel attached.
When it was published in a national fly fishing magazine, there was a huge outcry from the purist fly fishing community that it was not a fly, but a lure.
It was accepted by many fishermen and today is popular among striped bass fishermen in many areas of the country.
Following years, Henry Cowen, fly fishing guide and fly innovator, came up with yet another spin fly version that he had accredited by the board of the IGFA, and the spinner fly will be qualified for any world record class fish.
Another innovation is currently taking place.
Years ago I began tying striped bass flies on a 60-degree bend jig hook, and early on it was frowned upon by the elitist fly fishing community.
It is now widely accepted and has become the �gold standard� for �hook point-up� flies.
An upcoming issue of Saltwater Flyfishing Magazine will recount the history.
There is no question in my mind that the pellet fly is a �match the hatch� fly and should qualify for any �private water� record.
I love driving those guys nuts... :p
A fly is anything that can be cast on a fly line...
