Bill,
First off, thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed response. I can tell you put a lot of effort into that post and I genuinely appreciate it. Your explanation is helpful for me to read through.
Based on your input, I’m trying to adjust my plan a bit so I’m not relying entirely on walleye for perch control and instead incorporate some predator diversity.
Right now I’m leaning toward something along these lines for my ~0.8 acre pond:
Forage base first:
- Fathead minnows
- Golden shiners
I may add in other things other than minnows if I need them.
Primary fish:
- 250 Yellow Perch (4–6")
Massive to me would anything 12” and up. Id be very happy with a perch that size.
Predators (non-reproducing focus):
- 1 Smallmouth Bass
- 3–4 Hybrid Striped Bass
- 2–3 Walleye
One important factor for me is that this pond will also be my household water supply. I working with my county on this and have a very reputable installer. Because of that I’m trying to keep the system as natural and clean as possible. I plan to avoid pond dye and chemical treatments if I can and instead manage vegetation biologically where possible (for example tilapia if needed). My goal is to keep the water as clear and healthy as possible.
Thanks again for sharing your experience and taking the time to explain all of this. I’ve learned a lot from your posts.
Last edited by 4-25RedLeg; 03/09/26 07:51 AM.
