Originally Posted by ewest
Bill is correct. What Bob is saying is (see brand new PB mag) that northerns don't consistently get to 10 lbs like Fla fish can. Even half the Fla fish don't get big - males are small. 60 to 70% of LMB size is dependent on conditions and the rest is genetics. Plus there is still a lot to learn about F-1 and F-X LMB. Many of the Texas share a lunker LMB are LMB intergrades with a high % Fla but some Northern genes. In both Northerns and Fla its not just genes but more importantly gene expression (size is not always expressed). Also keep in mind that the upper geographical limits of pure Fla LMB is uncertain. In one study in WI they all died due to cold. I would not personally stock pure Fla LMB north of I-40 or at high elevation as the results would be less than desired.

Great conversation, I must have missed the key word "consistently". I would certainly never intentionally misquote anyone. Definitely not Bob on his own forum smile

According to the Oklahoma State Fishery manager where my LMB came from, they provide Northern LMB. Since that's where my fish came from this is awesome news to me!!


2 Acre, Completed July 2022, CC,BG, Sept. 2022, LMB June 2023, GSF, YBH invasion in 2022. BG, CNBG, RES, 2025, TP seasonal.