Originally Posted by J. E. Craig
Many many moons ago, I remember a member losing some LMB because of a large heron wounding his fish by stabbing them with his beak.

I caught a weak fish,13.5"" male 77% RW, that I thought was just a small branch caught on my line, no fight. He had a 1/2 inch round dorsal wound slightly behind his head & near his spine. It was down to the bone, 3/8" deep, not through & through & not fresh. I had first thought it was a stress fungal lesion, LMB just off their beds. When I opened his abdomen foul grey-black water poured out. Later I wished I had checked to see if the wound was contiguous with his abdomen. I only did a quick pinky probe. I do have a Great Blue & large White Heron that patrol the banks daily. This is my first time seeing something like this.

If a heron or osprey kills a fish, the fish deserves it!

Comments & thoughts Appreciated.

So no problem then, your fish obviously deserved it.

I caught a similar LMB that had a completely fresh hole stabbed all the way through it, it was dead within minutes.

I am with DD1, I am not a fan of them, especially not stabbing a fish that is too big for them to eat or handle, just killing them because they can, my fish didnt deserve to die that way.


All the really good ideas I've ever had came to me while I was milking a cow.