Golden shiners would be a good idea to get established. I always like to do a mix of fatheads and shiners when stocking a pond. Check your state regulations to see if yellow perch are even allowed. You are a little far south for them to do too well, and they may not be on your states approved species list. I know they aren't in Arkansas.

If I were you I would look to establish redear sunfish at the same time you stock the fatheads, shiners, and bluegill.