I'm in the camp...if you own a private pond and can't catch bass the way you want to, you are doing something wrong. (or you have trespassers or water turkeys) \:\) Granted, fishing will not be "great" every day, but you liked getting exhausted catching the 1-3 lb bass right ? Managing a pond for bass in the 2-4 lb. range is completely different than managing for 6+ bass. I have always preferred the 2-4 lb. range with a sporatic lunker, that may explain the differences between my ponds, and ML & George. If you don't have Lusk's book, get it immediately.