I have used several dozer operators and they came with varying degrees of skill and integrity. The NRCS will probably not recommend one operator over another. I would do a couple of things. First, design the ultimate pond that you want. In effect, look for an operator who can make you happy, not just push dirt or dam up a draw. Second, ask the NRCS for a list of ponds that they have assisted and call the land owners. Ask who they used and what their feelings are. Would the guy be their first call for their next job? Also, did their pond have any special features that woulld attract fish or did they just build a dam? Can you come look?What kind of equipment do they use? A new D6 will do almost as much work as an older model D8. On old D5 will take forever and you are paying by the hour. The technical part of this can probably be answered at a dozer sales place. I would check and do my homework. There is a very recent discussion here about cubic yards measurement. Once you know how big you will make the pond, define the cubic yards to be moved. This is how the NRCS pays and most of these guys are used to cooperating with the NRCS and getting NRCS oversight. If they won't do it for you at that rate, get very suspicious and back slowly out of the room.

Two dozers worked on my pond. One of them could make a dozer stand on its ear. The other could only grub mesquite and push dirt. Be very careful. A lot of operators will spend a lot of time in granny gear when they need to be going in road gear. Expect the really right guy to be busy, not idle. The list of dozer operators that I won't use again is a lot longer than the ones that I will use. Again, be very careful. Once the project is complete, it is too late to say "I wish I had......."