I too would like to hear more thoughts on using big catfish to control the crappie population. It is my understanding that big flatheads won't spawn in a small-medium sized pond, and rarely so in even a big lake. Does anybody have any more info to support this?
I've always been led to understand that they need a river or other moving body of water to be enticed into spawning activity.
With that in mind, I would think that a 3 acre pond could easily support a small population (10 or so) of flathead catfish that would work wonders to keep the crappies in control while offering some rod breaking potential fun!
JMHO of course...
I am putting it to the test as I write this...I've recently introduced crappie to a small pond (approx 1.5 acres) and I plan on catching some small/medium flatheads this summer for release into the pond. I'm hoping the flatheads will also help keep the Bluegill from stunting as well.
I realize that it will probably be 3 years or so before I can tell if this strategy is working or failing miserably. If worst comes to worst, I plan on shocking the crappies into submission!Time will tell.
One note: the pond in question is already supporting a real good population of channel cats in the 2-3 lb range. We love catching the cats and releasing them for another day, although I think the cats have taken a toll on the Largemouth Bass population
. Oh well, I personally enjoy catching the cats better!
I am planning a fish fry soon to help relieve some of the pressure on the Largemouth Bass.
Good luck all. This is a great site.
