Thanks for the response! Yes, I am very familiar with Eagle River - I took many vacations there as a kid and now take my family up in that general area every summer! We live in Muskego (southwest of Milwaukee).

Our primary goal for the pond is to have it look nice and hopefully let the kids swim in it. Next year, we would like to stock some fish, but I'm not sure what kind.

I have attached a picture of the pond (I think), so that maybe you can get a better idea of what we are dealing with. It is still very cloudy from the aerator, but I'm hoping that as we let it run longer, that will clear up.

Right now, we have turtles and frogs in the pond. There might be some fish, but I don't know this for sure...

Thanks again for all advice and help!

Attached Images
20170522_1842402.jpg