I have read a lot about managing deer even though as Scott explained earlier that in some areas like his and mine it's a waste of time to an extent... And what you are saying works in a controlled environment like a horse farm, pond, or high fence area... The problem with free range deer is they don't read the same books or use the same logic we do...

Inevitably that deer no matter if its the largest or smallest in the woods it is going to do its best to live, reproduce and eventually die... Left to go unchecked we all know where that goes... Is shooting the biggest buck in the woods right or wrong?.. I'll leave that up to you, that's what nice about this county...