So after taking all the advice on other posts so far, I'm just trying to figure out which would be better suited for my pond. There is no rush since I have to allow my other population build first. But here goes.

7 1/2 feet deep
1/2 acre in size
Healthy supply of FHM and Shiners
Healthy supply of BG
Aeration throughout winter to keep O2 healthy

Once the above is in place and pond is stable I plan on choosing one type of bass and adding it to the pond. Based on the above and the fact that I am in Ontario Canada lets hear some pros and cons for both.