Anthony,
I fully agree with nearly all of what has been posted above.
Since New York state is so big, and because it ranges from the rather temperate areas along the lower Hudson River valley and Long Island Sound, to the near-permafrost northern areas, it is difficult to make good suggestions.
I'd suggest that you get in contact with our very good Pond Boss friend, Dr. Mark Cornwell, at SUNY Cobleskill. Nobody knows more about raising fish in NY State than Dr. Cornwell. You can find contact info here:
SUNY Cobleskill Fisheries Staff Contact Info Ken
