I fully agree that the nature of aquifers is not understood conclusively. I also think that geography, or location will impact specific aquifers. I have no idea how deep the well at my pond is, as it was drilled long ago. However, I do know the one here at the shop went down 96'. The driller was amazed that it was able to supply 25 gpm, as he claimed that 10-15 gpm was very good for my area. Based on his remarks, it would seem that very little action would be required to impact such a well. Again, that's just my area. I read on here of guys routinely getting 50 gpm, or even more, so I'm sure that different areas can supply varying amounts before any impact might be felt. MIGHT be felt. Might not. That's the unknown variable.....
My only reason for commenting on this thread was due to TJ's remarks about feeling a little guilty. I also didn't intend to engage in a debate over morality, I only wanted to show that I too have felt the same way as he does, or did.
IMO no problems so far on this topic. However I caution anyone from making and expressing moral judgments about someone else's legally allowable use. The law after all is society�s judgment on what is required of our behavior.
Ewest, I understand and appreciate your position, but I must respectfully disagree. Laws get changed all the time, and I believe that making and expressing moral judgements is a primary tool by which such change is accomplished. Standing up for what you feel is right is a moral, albeit sometimes emotional, obligation. That doesn't mean it's always politically correct, or popular, or easy. But sometimes it's necessary.
Before the ropes and pitchforks come out, let me say that I'm not advocating for change in the way the water laws are currently written. I have stated before in this thread that I think everybody's circumstances are different, and should be evaluated one on one.
Just because I decide not to pump, doesn't mean that I think everyone should follow my example. If you're operating within the law, then you should do what you think is right. That's how I see it.
