I'd be going with #2. More protein and cheaper. A higher % of the ingredients are vegetable, but I don't think the BG will mind and I'm sure the CC won't.

Don't worry about those cats being smaller than you'd like. If you keep feeding, they'll keep growing and growing and ...

"Live like you'll die tomorrow, but manage your grass like you'll live forever."
-S. M. Stirling
[Linked Image from i.pinimg.com]