Well, I think we have narrowed it down. I took a pic from the link you sent and placed my pic next to it and the only difference I see is the coloration of the lateral stripe.

Moving on to the next problem...As I was walking around today I found a 5-6" catfish in a very small puddle of water. I tried to catch it but it disappeared into a hole which at first I thought must have been a crawfish hole. That hole must have been a foot deep. Where there is one, there are others and I definitely didn't want any type of catfish in my pond. I guess they can help to keep the crappie in check?? Trying to find the silver lining here.

Thanks again for the help, guys!
Attachments
Photo0245.jpg