I would like to see a shaper image of the other fish and maybe one that is a little closer of the head. Technically the upper jaw length of a warmouth should extend backward to the middle of the eye. I don't see that occurring in the other fish photo. Warmouth do occur in WI.
For the LMB, possibly Rainman will be making a delivery to WI soon or this fall. Also check with Nate Herman. They may be able to deliver you fish included in another order.
If you want second opinions of google fish identifications provide links. Beware of Google images.
