When I fished regularly for crappie, #2, many times. The hook wouldn't straighten completely of course; it would bend just enough to come free from the snag; but of course the bending is what would also lose the fish, in this case a carp. But you didn't say six-pound - you said ten-pound, which will bend an aberdeen hook like clockwork. Crappie guides on Kentucky and Barkley Lakes actually use aberdeen hooks with ten-pound test so they can straighten the hook when they get snagged.

I made a simple and highly relevant and sound recommendation simply out of a desire to help the poster avoid the frustration of losing fish and finding himself at the pond without the right terminal tackle. I really don't wish to argue something that should be common sense.