Not that you eat too much fish... Just that 2 ponds totaling 2 acres may not able to to sustain that amount of harvest it would require to keep up with your demands. Particularly if you use SMB/RES...
How about common carp? When raised in clean waters they are actually very good eating IMO. They are fast growing, high fecundity and will meet your demands... The rest of the world uses them for a reason. Us Americans just decided long ago we were too good for them.
As far as bluegills causing an issue in swimming ponds it because they have a tendency to nip at swimmers. It isn't really painful, but more of an annoyance...
