Reasonable minds can disagree on a lot of things.
I'm just a South Texan, but I'd say that pike and tiger muskie would need to be monitored carefully in small waters. Same thing with the alligator gar down here that wash in after a flood.
Big predators eat a lot of food.
There's a big difference between saying that "x" fish should NEVER be stocked versus weighing the pros and cons to make an educated decision. It seems to me CJ was saying the latter.