Update on this thread:
I ended up driving to Buffalo, TX to pick up some fish from Overton Fisheries. I purchased 250 F1 and 250 Florida fingerlings at 2", 10 pounds of large golden shiners, 1000 coppernose bluegill, and 20 pounds of Tilapia. The fish did well on the trip home with only a few morts. Todd credited me for the ones that didn't make it.
I picked up the fish on Wednesday, June 3rd and put them in the pond that evening.
Yesterday, while riding around the edges throwing fish food, I noticed a Tilapia with thousands of fry swimming around. Now, I have Tilapia fry in the pond 12 days after stocking.
I'm impressed with the quality of fish Todd Overton sells and will be doing business with him again in the future.