Todd :

Good topic to start. We don't post enough about possible options for small (use your 1 acre) ponds which many people have.

One thing that may surprise many is that quite a few state agencies recommend HBG and CC for small ponds. They do so as a stock grow out/fish out and restock option. It is easy to manage and you rarely see any questions of balance.

If you want other fish with this option then add FH and RES. I would probably not put HSB in such a small pond in my location unless there was aeration and a new cool water source for exchange. But the more factors you add the more management is required. If I had to have a second predator I would use female LMB in low numbers as a bonus fish.

Another option is FH/Gamb. and male only BG/RES and a single sex predator of choice in low numbers.

Still another if you will manage a put and take fishery is FH/Gamb. ,tilapia and trout with another single sex predator. Stock the tilapia or trout( summer and winter in adult sizes and grow them and harvest them before they succumb to the temps.

Another is a trophy BG/RES pond with overcrowded LMB to keep the BG/RES #s down. Don't manage the LMB let them stunt . Catch and restock adult BG and RES and if you catch a big LMB 4 lbs up harvest it.

I think there are some really good options for more northern ponds where YP and SMB are options.

Well that is a start. A good topic to brain storm some thoughts.

Warning this is a brain storming topic for ideas. No one go off on a wild tangent and try one of these with out thinking through the options . No one get bent out of shape if someone posts an unusual idea and no personal " that is a stupid idea" replies.Who knows we may all learn something .