In last years thread on this subject. I read where people were leaning towards the Black Crappie because they feed better on Plankton and are some what less dependent on fish. While the white crappie needed a better bait fish forage to thrive. So everyone favored the "Black crappie as the lesser of the two evils.

Now, this year, there is a new thread started with talk of White Crappie as the favorite, what gives? Why the change of heart? Have people NOW found an advantage to White Crappie all of a sudden. If so what is it>

You all know my "funcky" pond situation by now, I'm SURE. I am just trying to figure on which species I have the best chance at for my conditions.

Sound like though if I choose White Crappie then I will need a good Threadfin Population