Forums36
Topics41,100
Posts559,549
Members18,586
|
Most Online3,612 Jan 10th, 2023
|
|
|
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 14,045 Likes: 301
Moderator Lunker
|
Moderator Lunker
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 14,045 Likes: 301 |
FWIW, our general consensus on GSF is that they are either a manageable problem or a non-problem. Worst case with GSF would be a pond where they have been the only (or the far-and-way dominant) species for some time, and have taken up virtually all the pond's available biomass with little stunted Greenies. One can manange one's way out of even that scenario successfully (without renovating).
In your case, they have a year (at most) head start on your CNBG. The Coppernose will out reproduce them, the bass will eat them (first, probably, since they are slenderer than CNBG), and, for your own personal information, they taste just like BG. Some of our PMs here operate or strive for trophy GSF ponds, and they wouldn't consider them any kind of problem.
P.S. Check out some of the threads on GSF (looking under "Jeff has a pond" would be a good start) and that should help you decide whether or not to pursue your GSF with extreme prejudice.
P.P.S. What are your management goals for the pond?
Last edited by Theo Gallus; 11/12/07 02:41 PM. Reason: Forgot the Greg Grimes question
"Live like you'll die tomorrow, but manage your grass like you'll live forever." -S. M. Stirling
|
|
|
Entire Thread
|
Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/12/07 06:51 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Bruce Condello
|
11/12/07 06:53 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/12/07 07:07 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Bruce Condello
|
11/12/07 07:23 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/12/07 07:36 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Theo Gallus
|
11/12/07 07:38 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/12/07 07:49 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Theo Gallus
|
11/12/07 07:52 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Shorty
|
11/12/07 08:14 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/12/07 08:32 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/12/07 08:50 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/12/07 09:11 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
bobad
|
11/12/07 09:39 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/12/07 09:39 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/13/07 03:03 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Cecil Baird1
|
11/13/07 03:17 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/13/07 03:45 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/13/07 02:34 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Cecil Baird1
|
11/13/07 03:20 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Cecil Baird1
|
11/13/07 03:35 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/13/07 03:52 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/13/07 03:55 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/13/07 03:38 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
overtonfisheries
|
11/13/07 04:10 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/13/07 05:21 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
dave in el dorado ca
|
11/13/07 06:04 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
overtonfisheries
|
11/13/07 09:04 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Bob Lusk
|
11/14/07 01:17 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/14/07 02:01 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/14/07 03:28 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/14/07 04:28 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/14/07 04:42 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/14/07 04:58 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/14/07 05:23 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/14/07 05:40 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/14/07 05:55 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
dave in el dorado ca
|
11/14/07 07:13 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/14/07 07:22 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Shorty
|
11/14/07 07:58 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/14/07 07:50 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/14/07 08:42 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/14/07 09:59 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/14/07 10:22 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
cliffbrook
|
11/14/07 10:46 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/14/07 10:54 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
bobad
|
11/15/07 03:23 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/16/07 12:43 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
archer
|
11/16/07 06:32 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Bill Cody
|
11/17/07 03:39 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/15/07 04:06 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Dave Davidson1
|
11/15/07 11:20 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/15/07 02:02 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/15/07 03:07 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
burgermeister
|
11/14/07 08:29 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/15/07 03:32 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Bill Cody
|
11/16/07 02:42 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
Theo Gallus
|
11/16/07 02:50 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/16/07 04:05 AM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
GW
|
11/14/07 05:17 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/14/07 04:37 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/13/07 02:36 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/13/07 03:08 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
ewest
|
11/13/07 03:38 PM
|
Re: Fish type, concern ??
|
jeffhasapond
|
11/13/07 03:56 PM
|
|
Moderated by Bill Cody, Bruce Condello, catmandoo, Chris Steelman, Dave Davidson1, esshup, ewest, FireIsHot, Omaha, Sunil, teehjaeh57
|
|