A few commnets Bill:
I question how many 2"+ fish that RES will eat per year in the wild setting. Size of the RES could also play a role here.
Size of RES definatley plays a role, when they were smaller a few months ago they prefered FHM under 1-3/4" long. Within five days of introducing smaller pet shop minnows they were eating 20-30 RRFHM a day and almost exclusively in the dark.
Small fish are better at escaping predation in the natural environment compared to being confined in the aquarium or tank habitat and not having to chase or actively attack the food.
I have a significant amount of stucture and current moving in my tank making predation more difficult. FHM do have places they can hide where my RES cannot get to them. Between the two powerheads and two filters I am moving ~ 840 GPH in a 75 gallon tank, this makes eating a FHM head first quite a challenge in my tank. It also make feeding and removing uneaten pellets very difficult.
We also have to consider that your current several RES in the fish tank have not had to forage in the wild for food. They have spent much of their life in a tank and being hand fed - conditioned to a life style.
They were on their own in the pond for 11 to 12 months before I put them in my pellet training program last May/June. I have had them for 10 months now.
My literature library is pretty limited when it comes to RES.
Aint that the truth, very little research has been done with RES. I know it defies conventional wisdom but I truly believe that someday RES will be viewed as a "dark adapted nocturnal sunfish" and that they move in shallow once the sun goes down. This probable dark adaptation is a niche that is not exploited by most other sunfish. A dark adapted predator should have an advantage over prey that does not see as well once the sun goes down.
Yes adult sized RES can eat 2" slender fish but do RES have the ability to capture those same fish in the natural setting?
If I am right about RES being dark adapted then the answer could very well be yes.
Another thing to consider is, will really slow naïve fish (FHM, YP resting) even be available as food when other much more efficient and more adapted predators are also present in the same habitat and likely consume the small fish very early "in the predator-prey game"? With other predators (juvenile bass etc) present with RES I wonder if small "dumb" fish will even wander into areas where the RES spend their forage (hunt) time. Are not RES more inclined to be found in the deeper water vs the shallow water 'haunts' of small fish?
Very valid point Bill, FHM are not known for their predator smarts and there are very few left in my pond, mostly large adults, but I do have an over abundance of small GSH. Last spring/summer I walked my pond after dark with a flashlight several times and observed RES in less than a foot of water along the edge of the pond but mostly what I saw were small GSH.
As a test it would be very interesting and educational to put a LMB (same length or weight as RES) in the aquarium with the RES. After a day or two, add the minnows and watch the results. I would like to know how many minnows the bass eats before the 1st RES eats a minnow.
The bass would win hands down given the larger gape and presuambly less light sensitive eyes. A more interesting test would be to match gape size for gape size, then turn out the lights and then examine stomach contents ocnce the lights are turned on.
I can quit posting about about my indoor RES if I am ruffling too many feather here but I am definatley hungry for more RES researh to done based on what I have observed.