I'd probably vote for the fatheads, but I'd also caution that you will probably have help in stocking that lake since you live far away. Probably uneducated and highly unhelpful help.

Unless you plan to drain it before stocking, I'd be tempted to buy or borrow at least some fatheads, bluegill, and redear fish followed up appropriately with some predator fish later to stock so it doesn't get all out of balance from the start.

[Linked Image from i108.photobucket.com]