I am a subscriber and new pond owner - I find the advice on here just great. I personally would pay for the continued paper magazine as THEO said for the throne value alone...
I would also pay for a bundle option of being able to get the paper magazine and read/post on the forums as long as the cost is reasonable.
I think you have some good suggestions and I think most of us all find the site as a very valuable reference. The key is maintain that balance of cost/value and I think you will.
just my two cents.
I subscribe!
1/3 Acre pond - Central, OH Deepest point 11 ft. Stocked with: Hybrid Bluegill, Bluegill, Yellow Perch, Largemouth Bass, White Amur.