Cecil-Do you think since I am having a hard time finding fatheads that I can go down to the local bait shop and buy some minnows and throw them in now and have success??
Absolutely. Just take a good look at them before you throw them in. Sometimes there are green sunfish mixed in (Sorry Jeff!LOL) and sticklebacks. (Actually even from a supplier you should look the fatheads over and make sure there are no greenies in with them.
One thing you may want to consider. Find out who supplies your local bait store and then call the supplier. You should be able to get a better price.