Pond Boss Magazine
http://www.pondboss.com/images/userfiles/image/20130301193901_6_150by50orangewhyshouldsubscribejpeg.jpg
Advertisment
Newest Members
bwj1040, Brian L, Landon, JosephNY, theo
16267 Registered Users
Forum Stats
16268 Members
36 Forums
37227 Topics
507224 Posts

Max Online: 2277 @ 12/03/19 04:57 PM
Top Posters
esshup 24044
Cecil Baird1 20043
ewest 20016
Dave Davidson1 14127
Bill Cody 13041
Who's Online
16 registered (NEDOC, Snipe, wbuffetjr, Bobbss, rjackson, sprkplug, bcraley, Custom 68, canyoncreek, bellojiafra, LeighAnn, Pond Star, Chris Steelman, Kris B, Bob Lusk, Theo Gallus), 686 Guests and 120 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Topic Options
#511737 - 09/19/19 12:15 AM How many times can you catch...?
Ryan M Offline


Registered: 08/10/19
Posts: 25
Loc: Western NY
Ok so Iíve been enjoying reading these forums. One thing Iíve seen a number of times is that you shouldnít release channels as they become hook shy. I would never have guessed this as I would expect a fish that hunts by smell and has relatively poor vision to be the easiest to fool multiple times. Curious what causes them to become hook shy? I would have guessed simply changing the bait would make it easy to fool them over and again.

Second question - how many times can you catch other species before they become uncatchable? I once caught a giant smb about four times in two weeks.

I would love to learn more about the reasons channels are hard to catch repeatedly and how they compare to other species with respect to repeated catchability.

Top
#511738 - 09/19/19 12:58 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
Snipe Online   content


Registered: 10/26/18
Posts: 761
Loc: NW Kansas
My opinion here.. Fish feed (or bite) for different reasons, one of which is hunger but another more important reason is a reaction strike. Keep in mind there are 2 perspectives on this. Anglers perspective and the biological perspective. An angler notes catching "X" fish 4 times-to the angler the fish "fed" 4 times. The biological perspective my be that this fish was caught due to being triggered in a reactive way, 3 of the 4 times. Instinct told the fish to react to an opportunity. It may not have been hunger. Cats trigger in a more direct way, their sense of smell and taste may lead from through a much longer period of time from picking up scent to actually coming across whatever that scent is. Cats have more time to learn a process and become shy much quicker than other species. It's "learned behavior", but they spend more time from scenting to eating. Several of our Hatchery personnel consider cats quite "smart" compared to other species.
The time period between catch events probably has more to do with it than anything. You might catch the same cat 2 times a year for 5-6-7 yrs, but it may not be interested in 5-6-7 times a summer.
_________________________
I Subscribe!

Top
#511742 - 09/19/19 09:13 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
nehunter Offline


Registered: 07/20/15
Posts: 123
Loc: SE, NE
I have caught a 6 lb. channel cat that had 2 hooks in it's mouth and 1 large hole where it had bin on a limb line for a long time. Plus my hook. So some don't learn.

Top
#511746 - 09/19/19 10:45 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
Quarter Acre Offline


Registered: 06/10/16
Posts: 1626
Loc: West Central Missouri
At my pond...if you catch one fish with a particular type of bait, it tells the others and significantly reduces any further bites. At this point, I think they have wised up beyond bait style and are now looking for the eye of the hook and/or the line, maybe even a bobber at the surface. I know this is not near entirely true, but it sure seems like it at times. And, I do not overfish, or should I say "over-catch" my pond. I have probably caught and returned 70 fish since it was stocked 1-1/2 years ago.

I have caught, at least one, HBG twice, but I would certainly bet it was different bait both times.

Somehow, I thought (prior to the pond build) that I was going to easily create a fish catching haven...really, how can a 1/4 acre pond with over 600 fish in it be so hard to catch a few fish, let alone fill a basket?

"Hook shy" is a concern of mine, but they can't get much harder to catch than they are right now. I think they are spoiled on natural foods and pellets.
_________________________
Fish on!,
Noel

Top
#511747 - 09/19/19 11:34 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
ewest Offline
Moderator
Hall of Fame 2014

Lunker

Registered: 03/08/05
Posts: 20016
Loc: Miss.
There is a lot here on catchability and articles in PB mag. Scientific articles with proof of catchability and its heritable nature.

See these and get the mag.


http://forums.pondboss.com/ubbthreads.ph...true#Post158885

http://forums.pondboss.com/ubbthreads.ph...true#Post466598




Edited by ewest (09/19/19 11:39 AM)
_________________________















Top
#511757 - 09/19/19 11:47 PM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
Ryan M Offline


Registered: 08/10/19
Posts: 25
Loc: Western NY
Thanks for the replies. Ewest I appreciate the links and will probably subscribe here shortly. Certainly a great resource worth supporting.

Snipe I appreciate the thought about the reaction strike being different than the more methodical proc as a cat goes through in seeking a meal. i am a bit curious why I only seem to see reference to channels becoming hook shy? Why would they be more apt to develop this trait than other cats? Or I s it simply a case that more channels are released in ponds than other cats - this we get more info about them.

I have been growing channels in a stock tank all summer and can see clearly that no two are alike. They all started out about the same size. Some are now exponentially larger than when I started. Others have grown very little. If growth rate is so variable it stands to reason that other traits like catchability or hook shyness could also be highly variable. Interesting stuff for sure and I appreciate the feedback on my question.

Top
#511765 - 09/20/19 09:12 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
jludwig Offline


Registered: 05/14/11
Posts: 1548
Loc: Central Kansas
Originally Posted By: Ryan M
I have been growing channels in a stock tank all summer and can see clearly that no two are alike. They all started out about the same size. Some are now exponentially larger than when I started. Others have grown very little. If growth rate is so variable it stands to reason that other traits like catchability or hook shyness could also be highly variable.


Genetics is interesting. It's amazing how widely it can vary in a group of the "same".


Edited by jludwig (09/20/19 09:12 AM)

Top
#511768 - 09/20/19 10:32 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
Bill Cody Offline
Moderator
Ambassador
Field Correspondent

Lunker

Registered: 04/18/02
Posts: 13041
Loc: Northwest Ohio - Malinta OH
All sorts of variability among individuals of all species is normal and is contributed to a large part due to genetics. Undoubtedly some fish species have the ability to become conditioned ("learn ability") better than other species. And just as in humans, some learn quicker than others.
_________________________
Keep This Forum Viable, Read Pond Boss Magazine -
America's Journal of Pond Management

Top
#511769 - 09/20/19 11:15 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
Funky Offline


Registered: 11/07/15
Posts: 110
Loc: Midland, Michigan
Just to add my opinion, I think sometimes we offer too much to our fish. A really good forage and feeding program and I seldom catch a LMB. The BG are just easy, but the larger ones are full from all the small ones. Or at least that is the way I see it. A friend with a nice large pond, mine is half-acre, says he stops feeding them 2-3 days before he wants to fish, just so the are hungry. Maybe that is the answer to better catches.
_________________________
half-acre pond, LMB, HBG, BG, GSH and CC ....goal is to
have fun fishing. And I subscribe!

Top
#511770 - 09/20/19 12:01 PM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Funky]
Quarter Acre Offline


Registered: 06/10/16
Posts: 1626
Loc: West Central Missouri
Originally Posted By: Funky
Just to add my opinion, I think sometimes we offer too much to our fish. A really good forage and feeding program and I seldom catch a LMB. The BG are just easy, but the larger ones are full from all the small ones. Or at least that is the way I see it. A friend with a nice large pond, mine is half-acre, says he stops feeding them 2-3 days before he wants to fish, just so the are hungry. Maybe that is the answer to better catches.


I can see the logic in that!
_________________________
Fish on!,
Noel

Top
#511776 - 09/20/19 03:32 PM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
ewest Offline
Moderator
Hall of Fame 2014

Lunker

Registered: 03/08/05
Posts: 20016
Loc: Miss.
That is an offshoot of compensatory feeding. Feed some then stop/slow and then after a pause feed again and they eat ravenously. In theory they eat more overall and thus grow faster. Your method is to catch them when they are waiting for the next feeding. I wonder if over time that will result in less effective results for that feeding method.
_________________________















Top
#511818 - 09/22/19 09:05 AM Re: How many times can you catch...? [Re: Ryan M]
jgr Offline


Registered: 06/23/15
Posts: 38
Loc: NE Iowa
I have never caught and released a CC but I continually can see them come to a bait, look at it or smell it and turn and leave it. I can once in a while catch one after the feeder goes and they be distracted due to the pellets. I now catch most on live minnows probably due to the movement of the minnow and not noticing the line or hook.
I have seen the very same thing now with the HSB. I can only catch them on live minnows. I have also never caught and released a HSB but have seen them come to a minnow on a hook and quickly turn and leave. I have thrown live minnows in the water and they attack them quickly but as soon as I put one on the hook they swim up to it and leave. We still will catch one of each once in a while but nothing like a couple years ago. Our water it quite clear and I am sure that has an effect but I think the hook shyness is for sure learned. Needless to say our CC and HSB are getting quite large.

Top

Today's Birthdays
Dustin Pratt, redfinger
Recent Posts
Chronicles of stocking Hybrid Striped Bass......
by NEDOC
01:10 PM
Slow around here lately?
by RStringer
11:39 AM
SMB / YP / RES - Now what?
by Freg
10:59 AM
8 acre pond at 10,000' - lots of aeration ?s
by wbuffetjr
09:24 AM
Organic Fertilizer or not?
by TGW1
07:46 AM
How Many Inches of Visibility?
by snrub
07:22 AM
OK, here's a tough question.
by RAH
06:37 AM
Stocking pond with fathead minnows
by texansfan
05:15 AM
Lime vs. Gyspon Experiment Results
by esshup
11:35 PM
It's time for war again!
by Pat Williamson
06:17 PM
Newly Uploaded Images
I Subscribe Permanent Link
Need Plants Identified - Texas Pond - Lily Pad ...
Personal Record BGxRES
Harry's Pond
pond view
Fishing Colorado...finally

© 2014 POND BOSS INC. all rights reserved USA and Worldwide