Pond Boss Magazine
Newest Members
AMS06, Buzzme, deersled, kasc70, drdugit
12862 Registered Users
Forum Stats
12862 Members
37 Forums
30325 Topics
411283 Posts

Max Online: 1039 @ 03/28/13 01:44 PM
Top Posters
esshup 20522
Cecil Baird1 18539
ewest 16861
Theo Gallus 12297
Dave Davidson1 11049
Who's Online
24 registered (FireIsHot, JamieE, Spicelanebass, Bob-O, TGW1, boater, FINnFUR, Zep, liquidsquid, JKB, Mkm, dreams of ponds, Ben Adducchio, RAH, george1, sprkplug, chrissnow, lassig, CMM, overtonfisheries, Theo Gallus, RobA, Cray, Bill D.), 271 Guests and 5 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Topic Options
#361015 - 12/25/13 12:55 AM Reintroducing Minnows
Zachary H Offline

Registered: 12/25/13
Posts: 6
Loc: Pennsylvania, USA
Hello, I have taken an interest in a recently conserved and partially reconstructed creek. the Conservation people came out and narrowed the creek in order to increase flow, because the creek was on the verge of drying up. It worked. Now, to my question. I love native fish so I am a fan of keeping fathead minnows. Fathead minnows tend to breed (a lot) and that resulted in an overpopulation. So, I was wondering if I could somehow take these healthy minnows and release them into the creek. If they bred there and after a few generations, would they attract bluegill sunfish, bass, and rainbow trout? or would I have to try and work with those and REINTRODUCE them, as well? (I said reintroduce because trout and minnows are native to that creek but disappeared after the creek widened and the water level sank. Now that the reek was conserved that problem is eliminated.)

#361019 - 12/25/13 06:01 AM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
RAH Online   content

Registered: 05/17/09
Posts: 2365
Loc: Indiana, Boone County, 25 mile...
My guess is that there are laws that prohibit you from introducing fish into a creek connected to other waters, but others will probably chime in with better information.

#361021 - 12/25/13 08:41 AM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
MSC Offline

Registered: 10/10/13
Posts: 339
Loc: Southern Maryland
Now that they fixed the creek, I bet this spring after a major rain event or snow melt, you will have the native fish and minnows back in the creek.
Free expert fishing tips. Just call BR-549.

#361053 - 12/25/13 10:21 PM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
Sunil Offline
Field Correspondent
Hall of Fame 2014


Registered: 09/03/03
Posts: 10316
Loc: Somerset, PA
Welcome to Pond Boss, Zachary H.

RAH brings up a good point. You have to assess your own situation, and consider what impacts your actions will have. For me, if I'm just doing things with species of fish that readily exist around the area, I wouldn't worry too much about it. BUT, that is not advising you to do so. Consult the PA Fish Commission rules for sure.

I don't know if fatheads reproduce in flowing streams or not.

I also agree with MSC that if the water levels reach year round flow with depth, fish will appear.
Excerpt from Gregory McDonald's "Fletch's Fortune:"
"Telegrams, sir. Two of them." He handed them over. "You weren't in your room earlier, sir."
"And sliding them under the door, you would have lost your tip. Right?"
The bellman smiled weakly.
"You've lost your tip anyway."

#361096 - 12/26/13 09:27 PM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
Zachary H Offline

Registered: 12/25/13
Posts: 6
Loc: Pennsylvania, USA
Thank you everybody for your input.

#361099 - 12/26/13 10:26 PM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
4CornersPuddle Offline

Registered: 01/24/11
Posts: 43
Loc: southwest Colorado
Zachary, welcome to the forum. You have a very interesting situation there.
Where in Pennsylvania are you? I grew up in se near Boyertown, way back in the 50s and 60s. We had a small creek, the Ironstone, that was a short walk from our small farm, so guess where I was all summer and most other times, too?
I remember carrying out a little bucket biology as a kid. I had a particular hole in the creek that was dear to me, so I once stocked it with a half dozen RBT and BT. They hung around for quite some time until one of the locals got word of them, caught them all, took them home to show them off to his family, then tossed them in the trash as he didn't like to eat fish. My first contact with a fish slob.
One other time I brought 6 or 8 SMB that I had caught from a creek downstream from the Ironstone. There were no SMB in the Ironstone for the 5 years before this. Those SMB that I released spawned and got a decent population going. We had very good smallmouth fishing up and down the creek after that. The pumpkinseed and the redbreasted sunfish increased in average size; the weedy creek chubs and fallfish were not nearly as much a problem after that. Why SMB didn't simply swim the 10 or so miles up to that part of the Ironstone from the larger downstream source always puzzled me. There were no dams or anything else to stop them from doing so.
It's been more that 40 years since I walked the banks of that stream. I often wonder what the fishery is doing now.
Good luck with your little creek. Please keep us posted.

#361127 - 12/27/13 11:06 AM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
Bill Cody Offline
Field Correspondent


Registered: 04/18/02
Posts: 9633
Loc: Northwest Ohio - Malinta OH
Try and check the down stream sections of the creek where it is significantly larger, wider and deeper by 2 or 3 times. Those fish will at times (spring & high water events) move into the upper stream reaches for spawning. Whatever fish are in the down stream watershed are okay to introduce back into your local area of the stream. Stream habitat will determine if or how well the added fish survive.

Fatheads will spawn in stream situations and they prefer the slower backwater or pool areas. I catch them in minnow traps set in small ditches and streams along with other various shiners and chubs. You can set minnow traps in the lower bigger portions of your stream to see what species are present and move some of them into the upper area of the stream near you. Once you get a community of forage fishes surviving in the upper stream, then you can consider reintroducing trout or other sport fish to the stream.

Edited by Bill Cody (12/27/13 11:08 AM)
Keep This Forum Viable, Read Pond Boss Magazine -
America's Journal of Pond Management

#361161 - 12/27/13 04:58 PM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
JKB Online   happy
Hall of Fame 2015

Registered: 12/03/09
Posts: 5704
Loc: Michigan
Browsing the Laws in PA. As an "individual", you will not "legally" be able to stock any aquatic species in any of the state waters. http://www.pacode.com/secure/data/058/chapter71/chap71toc.html

You need to read much, much more than this tho.

They do have a neat Cooperative Nursery program, but you have to have a legal setup with board members, bylaws and all that jazz, but you'll get a free Colonoscopy thru the process. laugh (means they'll just check you out really good)

You mentioned a conservation club? (which would be appropriate by law) Maybe you can find out more about this group and join.

If you just start tossing fish in on your own, and they find out, you will not want to be you!

Michigan is pretty easy about this for an individual wanting to help out. It's a free permit with a process involved, but you have to buy the fish from certified disease free sources. Can't just pull them out of your pond or a tank in your garage or basement and toss them in the river.

PA has some pretty strict law's, as do most Great Lake States. One permit I ran across, that had no explanation, was a permit to extend Trout fishing season in a private pond. That one for me, has a couple question marks on it??

To give you a perspective on this. The only fish your allowed to put into a State BOW, is one that you caught out of that same State BOW.

It's nice that you want to help tho, but there are protocols, procedures, rules and regulations.

#361253 - 12/28/13 11:33 PM Re: Reintroducing Minnows [Re: Zachary H]
Zachary H Offline

Registered: 12/25/13
Posts: 6
Loc: Pennsylvania, USA
Once again, thank you everybody for enlightening me on this subject. It is winter so I do have until springtime to consider the factors in this release. Between now and then I learned I will have to do a lot of research on PA laws, possible exceptions to those laws, permits, etc. But hopefully, by the spring I will have this all sorted out and be able to go through with the reintroduction.


Today's Birthdays
BWPearson, Fish1234, Jonathan Richardson, scott mayer
Recent Posts
Log Cabin in Texas
by Zep
0 seconds ago
Fishing 2015
by JamieE
8 minutes 11 seconds ago
No Longer Alone in the USA for 45 Days
by Bob-O
17 minutes 16 seconds ago
New to me 3 acre pond
by TGW1
19 minutes 26 seconds ago
Pond site may be a wetland?
by Bob-O
20 minutes 17 seconds ago
sick fish question
by TGW1
30 minutes 14 seconds ago
Happy birthday
by Bob-O
37 minutes 24 seconds ago
by sprkplug
48 minutes 7 seconds ago
GGR Trip report 6/26-6/27
by sprkplug
Today at 07:16 AM
I think I am finally going to aerate
by chrissnow
Today at 06:57 AM
Newly Uploaded Images
Fish ID
top view dam
overflow box
Aerator Enclosure/ cabinet
fish id
Hydro dozer

2014 POND BOSS INC. all rights reserved USA and Worldwide