Fish for pond where don't want fish - 05/26/09 11:09 PM
I've lost my previous post on this and couldn't find it. Still not settled.
Basically, I know someone who has a 2 - 3 acre pond which they use for drinking water. They don't want fish in it - except for maybe a very few to help control other critters and to eat any undesired fish that might get in it. I had thought about the HSB; but I don't think he wants to feed them regularly and they would have to dine on whatever they could find. We have discussed LMB of one sex. The obvious concern with that is judging sex. Recently, I decided that maybe some SMB might be the answer with the thought that they might do a good job controlling frogs and other critters, I could catch and transfer lots of them, and we could add a tiger musky or two to control their numbers if they really got out of control. He really doesn't want it to be a fishing pond. I don't think he is really sold on the SMB theory and is not convinced that it'd be safe for grandkids near the water if musky are put in it. What are your recommendations?
P.S. I was told today by someone bankfishing over the weekend beneath a big local lake. Someone near them caught a huge musky (sounds like could have been state record), drug it up on the bank, and hit it repeatedly on the head with a big rock complaining about gars and muskies ruining the fishing...
Basically, I know someone who has a 2 - 3 acre pond which they use for drinking water. They don't want fish in it - except for maybe a very few to help control other critters and to eat any undesired fish that might get in it. I had thought about the HSB; but I don't think he wants to feed them regularly and they would have to dine on whatever they could find. We have discussed LMB of one sex. The obvious concern with that is judging sex. Recently, I decided that maybe some SMB might be the answer with the thought that they might do a good job controlling frogs and other critters, I could catch and transfer lots of them, and we could add a tiger musky or two to control their numbers if they really got out of control. He really doesn't want it to be a fishing pond. I don't think he is really sold on the SMB theory and is not convinced that it'd be safe for grandkids near the water if musky are put in it. What are your recommendations?
P.S. I was told today by someone bankfishing over the weekend beneath a big local lake. Someone near them caught a huge musky (sounds like could have been state record), drug it up on the bank, and hit it repeatedly on the head with a big rock complaining about gars and muskies ruining the fishing...