It comes down to a couple things..
Do you want the pond anymore?
Do you want to spend the money to fix it? (if so nows the time, drain it completely).
The pond is a very nice addition to my place when it's full and on the flip side, it's an eyesore when it's low....... It's fed by a creek on the north end (through the spillway). The creek only runs during runoff rains. I've considered a well but obviously the leak needs to fixed first.
I'm willing to spend the money to have the dam leak repaired, but I'm needing advice on the best way to approach this. The leak in the dam is at the top(10x100'area) with no basin issues, so I don't see the need to completely drain it.