I think the best thing you can do is try all these fish that are suggested. Nobody can tell you what your taste buds like. You will find in this thread, and past ones, that about 4 or 5 fish will consistently come to the top of the list.
I would find a friend or nearby lake that has these, go get some, clean them yourself(this will keep the "test" factor more on equal terms) and see what you like. I don't think you can even try all of them fairly if different people cook them, because it won't be like how you do it. Perhaps you will like ones of these more than the fish you mentioned trying.
Certainly worth the time and effort if you compare it to what managing the pond, stocking costs, and changing you mind later will cost if you don't like it.
